Brotherhood Wine Club
The Brotherhood Wine Club is a flexible, curated subscription experience designed to evolve with you. Start with a balanced default selection, then tailor every shipment to your preferences—red, white, sparkling, or anything in between.
As a member, you’ll have access not only to American wines, but also to thoughtfully selected bottles from Chile, South Africa, Argentina, and beyond—offering a broader view of the wine world while staying true to Brotherhood’s standards of quality and character.
Our system learns what you enjoy over time, helping us recommend wines you’ll love—while you remain in full control of every shipment. Each club shipment includes a minimum of six bottles, with totals that reflect your evolving preferences and are always visible and editable before shipping.
No rigid categories. No locked-in styles. Just great wine—from near and far—delivered on your schedule.
Member Benefits
- FREE SHIPPING for New York, Massachusetts, Maryland, and District of Columbia club members
- DISCOUNT SHIPPING for Florida, Minnesota, and Nevada club members
- 10% OFF all wines available online
- Two complimentary guided public tour & tasting tickets
- Ability to customize every shipment
- Choose your shipment frequency
- Discover new and limited wines
- Access to member-only promotions
- Invitations and special pricing on events
- First access to new wine releases
Minimum of one shipment required when joining.
How it Works
1. JOIN THE CLUB
Enter your information and choose your shipment frequency. You’ll be charged for the wines in your shipment (plus tax and shipping, if applicable) when your package ships. Your first shipment ships two days after sign-up.
2. CUSTOMIZE YOUR SHIPMENT
Each shipment includes a minimum of six bottles. Before it ships, you can add, swap, or remove wines from our full selection. A 10% club discount is applied automatically.
We’ll send reminder emails two weeks and two days before shipment so you can review your selections. As your tastes evolve, our system helps recommend wines you’re likely to enjoy—while you remain fully in control.
Your shipment total always reflects your selections and is visible and editable before shipment.
3. ENJOY WINE & CLUB BENEFITS
Enjoy the convenience of regularly scheduled wine deliveries—set it and forget it, or adjust anytime.
“Brotherhood is a living, thriving, evolving center for wine and wine education, and a model for the wine industry.”
– Wine Enthusiast magazine
FAQ
Can I customize the wines in my wine club shipments?
Yes! You can exchange and add wines to your package. All club packages require a minimum of 6 items. An e-mail confirmation will be sent to you two weeks before each shipment with a deadline date for any changes you would like to make. Call or e-mail us for assistance with changing your club shipment.
Are all wines available to ship to every state?
Due to state regulations, shipping options vary by location.
For club members shipping to Massachusetts, shipments are limited to Brotherhood-produced wines only. World and non-Brotherhood selections are not available for shipment to Massachusetts.
If you ship to another eligible state, your club shipments may include both Brotherhood wines and select world wines. You can always review and customize your shipment before it ships.
Do subscription club members get benefits when visiting the winery?
Yes. Club members receive two complimentary public tour & tasting tickets upon signing up (the member plus one guest).
When visiting the winery, simply present a valid photo ID. Our team will confirm your active club membership at check-in.
- A club member must be present to redeem the benefit
- The benefit is non-transferable
When do you charge my card?
When your account is created, we take a credit card authorization to hold your wines. Your card is charged right before the wines leave our facility. If your card declines for a shipment we will reach out to you to update your account. You can update your credit card by logging in to your account or by calling us at (845) 496-3661.
When can I expect my first wine shipment?
Your first wine shipment goes out 2 days after sign up. The date of each subsequent shipment depends on your chosen shipment frequency (default is a 3 month frequency).
Is there a minimum number of wines in the club packages?
Yes, all packages require a minimum of 6 items. You can exchange and/or add items to the package.
Can I control the frequency of wine shipments?
Yes, you can control the frequency of wine shipments. We offer 1 month, 2 month, 3 month and 4 month frequencies. Frequencies can be edited after sign up by logging in to your Brotherhood account and going to Club Memberships.
What happens if you have the wrong shipping address or I am not available to sign for it?
Please contact our customer service team if your address is incorrect. We can have your packages held for pick up or redirected to the correct address.
We recommend setting up an account with UPS for enhanced tracking and delivery options. UPS will make up to three delivery attempts, excluding weekends and holidays. Please note there will be a $15 fee for any packages returned to us.
How long do I have to pick up my wines?
Will call orders will be held for 30 days. After 30 days, you will be charged a $15 restocking fee.