Skip to main content


Friday, December 1st
7 PM - 9 PM


Santa's Slay.
Comedy Murder Mystery Dinner
December 2 • 7 PM - 11 PM


Oldest Wine Cellars

Excavated by hand in the late 19th Century, the dimly lit cellars house over 200 oak barrels.



Brotherhood has the flexibility to offer a number of venues on our property for staging your special day.


Free Shipping!

Order 6+ bottles and get FREE GROUND SHIPPING to New York, Maryland, Massachusetts and District of Columbia.


Join Our
Wine Club!

Become a club member and start enjoying the benefits today!

“The purity of our wines was our pride and first consideration.”

– Charles Jacques, 1839-1886

Murder Mystery Dinner

D.O.A Mysteries presents Santa’s Slay

“Slay” bells will be ringing when someone unveils a stockingful of murder at the annual party for the Grinch International Factory of Toys at Brotherhood Winery. Become one of Santa’s little helper detectives and immerse yourself in this holiday murder mystery.  Join us for a holly jolly evening of food and drink, spiced with a dash of comedy and murder under the mistletoe.

December 2nd, 2023 • 7:00 – 11:00 PM

Includes dinner, open wine bar and show.  Must be 21 or older to attend.

Journey back to where wine-making is still an art.

America’s Oldest Winery is only about an hours drive from New York City.

New York Premium Selection


The Story of Brotherhood

America's Oldest Winery Est. 1839
by Robert Bedford

Join our
Mailing List!

Get discounts on select wines.

First dibs on event tickets.

New wine updates.